Protecting Your Case and Your Future in Massachusetts

Choosing a lawyer for both criminal and immigration cases may be one of the most important decisions a non-citizen facing charges in Massachusetts can make. A plea that looks minor in criminal court can lead to deportation, denial of a green card, or loss of a path to citizenship under federal immigration law. Toland Law, LLC is a Boston firm focused on both immigration law and criminal defense, so one team can look at your criminal case and your immigration status together. For many of our clients, the real stakes are their family and their future in the United States.

If you or a loved one is facing criminal charges and you are not a U.S. citizen, contact Toland Law for a free consultation. Call 781-819-3647 or schedule your consultation now. Better Call Paul!

wooden shelf holding government envelope, letter, newspapers beside hanging key

Why Criminal Defense and Immigration Law Cannot Be Separated

The U.S. Supreme Court has made clear that immigration consequences are part of a defense lawyer’s job. In Padilla v. Kentucky, 559 U.S. 356 (2010), the Court held that the Sixth Amendment requires defense counsel to tell a noncitizen client when a guilty plea carries a risk of deportation. When the law clearly makes deportation presumptively mandatory, counsel must say so. When the law is not succinct and straightforward, counsel must at least warn that the plea may carry a risk of adverse immigration consequences. Because this is a federal constitutional decision, it applies in every state, including Massachusetts. The Supreme Court later held in Chaidez v. United States (2013) that Padilla does not apply retroactively to convictions that were final before March 31, 2010. However, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court held in Commonwealth v. Clarke (2011) that, under Massachusetts law, Padilla applies to convictions that became final after April 1, 1997.

The Court also rejected the idea that deportation is just a "collateral" issue outside a defense lawyer’s duties. Failing to address immigration risk may amount to ineffective assistance of counsel under the Strickland v. Washington standard, which generally requires showing both deficient performance and prejudice. That can become grounds to challenge a conviction, but usually only after the damage may already be done.

What This Means When You Hire a Lawyer

Knowing the constitutional rule is different from knowing how a specific charge will play out in immigration court. A lawyer who handles only criminal cases may give a general warning that a plea "could" affect your status. A lawyer who also practices immigration law can look at how a specific charge, plea, or sentence may be treated under federal law before you agree to anything.

💡 Pro Tip: Do not sign any statement or document, and do not accept any plea deal, until you have spoken with a lawyer who understands both criminal and immigration consequences.

How a "Good Deal" in Massachusetts Can Still Create Immigration Problems

Some outcomes that look favorable under Massachusetts law can still count against you under federal immigration law. Under M.G.L. c. 278, § 18, a defendant in the Boston Municipal Court, a district court, or a juvenile court may plead not guilty or guilty, or, with the court’s consent, plead nolo contendere or admit to sufficient facts. If the defendant and the Commonwealth cannot agree on a recommended disposition, the defendant may still tender a plea or admission with a request for a specific disposition, and may withdraw it if the judge imposes a harsher one.

The Continuance Without a Finding Trap

A continuance without a finding (CWOF) is a common Massachusetts resolution that many people believe is harmless. Under M.G.L. c. 278, § 18, a defendant may ask that no guilty finding be entered and that the case be continued to a specific date and then dismissed if conditions are met. In state court, this often feels like a win. Federal immigration law, however, defines "conviction" on its own terms under 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(48)(A). An admission to sufficient facts combined with any punishment, penalty, or restraint on liberty ordered by the judge, such as probation conditions or fees, is generally treated as a conviction for immigration purposes, even if the case is later dismissed.

This is exactly where having one firm handle both sides matters. Common situations where we see this risk include:

  • OUI charges resolved with a CWOF, which may affect green card or citizenship applications
  • Assault and battery or domestic violence charges, which may carry separate immigration grounds
  • Drug charges, where even low-level offenses can create serious immigration exposure
  • Admissions to sufficient facts that people assume will "disappear" after dismissal

You can learn more about OUI and immigration status in our related article. The immigration effect of any plea should be reviewed before it is entered.

💡 Pro Tip: Ask your lawyer directly how a proposed disposition would be viewed under federal immigration law, not just whether the case will eventually be dismissed in state court.

The Show Cause Hearing Massachusetts Non-Citizens Should Not Ignore

A show cause hearing can be the best opportunity to stop a criminal case before it begins. Under M.G.L. c. 218, § 35A, a person who is not under arrest and faces a misdemeanor complaint generally must be given a chance to be heard, personally or through counsel, before any criminal process issues. The same right applies when a law enforcement officer files a felony complaint and asks that the person not be arrested. For a felony complaint from someone other than police, the hearing is at the court’s discretion.

There are important exceptions. No hearing is required if there is an imminent threat of bodily injury, of a crime being committed, or of flight from Massachusetts by the person accused.

For a non-citizen, the outcome of this hearing can matter enormously. If no complaint issues, no criminal case is opened, which may help prevent immigration problems from starting. If you or a family member receives a show cause notice, contact a lawyer right away rather than attending alone.

💡 Pro Tip: Bring the show cause notice and any police paperwork to your consultation so your lawyer can begin preparing before the hearing date.

Undoing Past Pleas: Massachusetts Immigration Warning Protections

Massachusetts law gives non-citizens a powerful tool when a court failed to give the required immigration warning. Under M.G.L. c. 278, § 29D, if the court did not give the warning and the defendant shows the plea may have led, or did lead, to deportation, exclusion, or denial of naturalization, the court must vacate the judgment on the defendant’s motion. This applies even if the person has already been deported. The defendant may then withdraw the plea or admission and plead not guilty.

The statute also includes protections that favor the defendant. If there is no official record showing the warning was given (an accurate docket sheet counts), the court presumes the defendant was not warned. A warning given at a different plea hearing does not satisfy the requirement. Toland Law lists vacating criminal convictions for immigrants as a dedicated practice area. In a past matter titled "Two Convictions Vacated for Prospective Lawful Permanent Resident," the firm addressed convictions for Assault and Battery with a Dangerous Weapon in the Boston Municipal Court, Brighton Division, and Drug Distribution in the Quincy District Court. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome in any future case.

What Our Recognitions Mean for Your Case

Recognition from independent sources offers outside evidence of how a firm serves its clients. Toland Law displays Top Attorneys recognition badges for 2022, 2023, and 2024, along with a BBB badge. Recognition across several consecutive years suggests consistency rather than a single good year.

Client feedback is another form of recognition that matters. The firm has nearly 500 Google reviews, including video testimonials, and many clients say they were treated like family. These signals do not predict the result of any case, but they reflect a pattern of professional courtesy, responsiveness, and respect.

Why You Should Choose Toland Law

Toland Law brings criminal defense and immigration law together under one roof. Founder Paul J. Toland, Esq. has practiced in Massachusetts since 2012 and began his career as a prosecutor in Worcester, which gives him insight into how prosecutors build cases. The firm’s Massachusetts criminal defense practice covers OUI, drug crimes, domestic violence, weapons charges, property crimes, sex crimes, probation violations, and record sealing. Its immigration practice includes removal defense, ICE custody, green cards, citizenship, waivers, and humanitarian relief.

Our team reflects the communities we serve. Paul Toland’s Colombian mother and American father gave him a deep appreciation of the immigrant experience. Attorney Juan C. Congote is originally from Bogotá, Colombia, and Attorney Abrafi Osei-Kofi is originally from Ghana. Over half of our staff speaks Spanish, and we also serve Portuguese-speaking clients, including Boston’s Brazilian community.

We advocate aggressively while giving frank and practical legal advice. We investigate each case, examine the evidence, question witnesses, and challenge probable cause, search and seizure, and Miranda issues where they exist. If the prosecutor will not drop a charge, we may ask the court to dismiss it where there are legal grounds, and we will go to trial if needed. Our published past results include matters in Waltham, Dedham, and Lowell District Courts, including a domestic violence case in which the complainant was trying to get our client deported.

💡 Pro Tip: You can reach Toland Law by text through WhatsApp, which many families find easier when a loved one has just been arrested.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common Questions About Criminal Defense and Immigration in Massachusetts

1. Do I really need a lawyer who handles both criminal and immigration law?

In many cases, yes. Under Padilla v. Kentucky, defense counsel must advise noncitizen clients about deportation risk, but how a plea will be treated in immigration proceedings often requires immigration knowledge. A firm that practices both can weigh those consequences before you make decisions.

2. Is a continuance without a finding safe for my immigration status?

Not necessarily. A CWOF under M.G.L. c. 278, § 18 may end in dismissal in state court, but an admission to sufficient facts combined with court-ordered conditions such as probation is generally treated as a conviction under federal immigration law.

3. Can an old guilty plea be undone if I was not warned about immigration consequences?

Possibly. Under M.G.L. c. 278, § 29D, if the court failed to give the required warning and you show the plea may have caused immigration harm, the court must vacate the judgment on your motion. If there is no record of the warning, the court presumes it was not given.

4. What should I do if I receive a show cause hearing notice?

Contact a lawyer right away. Under M.G.L. c. 218, § 35A, you may be heard personally or through counsel in opposition to a complaint, and if no complaint issues, no criminal case begins.

5. Does Toland Law handle criminal cases outside Massachusetts?

No. Toland Law’s criminal defense practice is limited to Massachusetts. Because immigration law is federal, the firm can assist with immigration matters for clients outside the state.

Your Family’s Future Deserves a Defense That Sees the Whole Picture

For non-citizens, a criminal charge is never only a criminal case. Massachusetts law offers real protections, from show cause hearings to the immigration warning requirement, and federal law requires defense counsel to address deportation risk. Working with a firm that understands both systems can help you avoid outcomes that look safe in state court but threaten your status, your family, and your future.

If you or a loved one is a non-citizen facing criminal charges in Massachusetts, reach out to Toland Law for a free consultation. Call 781-819-3647 today or contact us now to protect your case and your future. Better Call Paul!

Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Every case is unique, and results may vary. Consult an attorney about your specific circumstances.

Toland Law, LLC